Kaylee's 2nd Reaction

            The next section of The Kite Runner uncovers more details about the relationship between Amir and Hassan, beginning with the incident with Assef. Assef is a disgusting in his views, however he is ignorant of the gravity of his words because it is obvious his father has heavily influenced him. It is painful to see how Amir fails to stand up for Hassan when Assef so blatantly disrespects him, yet Hassan stands up to Assef when Amir is in danger. In regards to their relationship, it is unsettling how Amir refuses to call Hassan his friend, but refers to him as a brother. Hassan is the closest thing to Amir as a friend and a brother. It is ironic how Amir only feels comfortable hanging out with Hassan when they are alone and does not openly refer to him as a friend, yet he views him as a brother – which constitutes blood relation. His ideas do no connect.  

            Hassan is my favorite character in the novel thus far. He stands up for Amir no matter what and supports him in everything he does. He finds beauty in the world around him and is content with the life he lives, never embarrassed of his social ranking. It disturbs me how Amir is so threatened by Hassan’s purity and goodness as a person and finds enjoyment in taunting him. Amir translates his insecurities into power over Hassan by testing his loyalty and tolerance of Amir. He knows that Hassan is naïve and uses this knowledge to take advantage of him. This side of Amir is discomforting and it portrays him in a negative light, however it is hard for me to blame Amir completely for his behavior. Under the circumstances of the society and how he has been raised with Baba, he is insecure in his quality of life and envious of Hassan, who has nothing, yet still lives in complete satisfaction. Amir’s situation brings up controversy in relation to of Nature vs. Nurture.

            I think the envy that Amir has of Hassan stems from love and affection that Hassan receives from Baba. Amir strives everyday for his father’s approval and it pains him that Hassan receives the same treatment as him. The contrast between the two boys is bound to cause some trouble and is definitely connected to the incident. The use of foreshadowing in this section prepares us for the events that follow. In addition, as chapter seven begins, the description of the beautiful day and Hassan’s dream featuring the two boys sets the mood, which is certain to be shattered.