Alex's Response to Maya's Reaction

     Maya, I feel that the scene between Hassan, Amir and Assef was included to emphasize the intolerance of the different subcultures in Afghanistan. By advocating Hitler's ideology, Assef is able to assert himself to Amir and Hassan, particularly Hassan because he Hazara. I agree that Assef has no right to think in this way because of the sharp differences between his background in comparison to typical Afghani features. Yes, Hassan could mock Assef in the same way he is being mocked, although his strong and rational personality prevents him from doing so. 

    I also began losing sympathy for Amir because more of his personality is shown throughout these few pages. His coldheartedness, which could also be described as selfishness is morphed by his envy towards Hassan and his superior natural abilities. Hassan's humble personality contrasts to Amir's jealousy of what Hassan's character possesses and he does not. It is clear that Baba's abandonment of Amir has gone too far. Through his father's attitude towards Amir, he is able to reach the conclusion that he has been responsible for his mother's death. The guilt laid upon him is what I believe is causing him to act this way. He wants to rise above Hassan to gain his father's approval and forgiveness. 

     Maya, I agree that Hosseini does a great job in recreating a childhood in an entirely different country and time period. He expands on the smallest details and although his writing is simple, I appreciate his directness.