Kaylee's Response to Ryan P.'s Reaction

            I, like Ryan, am starting to like Amir more as the story goes on. I never blamed him solely for his decisions because his upbringing and culture are definitely important factors of how he handed things. He did indeed act like a heartless little b*tch at times, but it is not entirely his fault. I am pleased to see that Amir is growing up into an accomplished young man. It is also clear that Amir is not a bad person because he does feel the guilt and pain from his decisions so far in his past. He is compassionate and sensitive to his surroundings.

            I also thought that Hossenini captured the journey from Kabul extremely well.  It is apparent that it is a pivotal moment for Amir and his father. I see where Ryan is coming from when he explains the death of Kamal and his father as the end of Amir's innocence and childhood. From this point, I think that Amir truly realizes the value of his life and begins the pathway to adulthood.

            I disagree with Ryan’s statement on the duo being very well acclimated to America in such a short transition period because the chapter suggests they have been living there for a year and a half. They are also not on the same page; Amir has completely embraced America, establishing himself as a student. While Baba has not and will never become fully adjusted to American living.